Rodney Samuels Consulting: The State Of The Market

With clearance rates holding but buyer confidence crumbling in key pockets, years of punitive policy against property owners is finally extracting its toll — and those who can least afford it are paying the price.

—————————————-

THIS WEEK’S NUMBERS

—————————————-

PDOL

Scheduled Auctions: 1,302

Reported: 651

Total Sold: 469

Passed In: 182

Clearance Rate: 72%

Domain

Scheduled Auctions: 1,160

Reported: 806

Total Sold: 465

Passed In: 213

Clearance Rate: 58%

—————————————-

On the surface, a 72% clearance rate looks respectable enough. 

Auctions are running, properties are selling, and the market is breathing. But peel back the headline number and a more troubling picture emerges one that has been years in the making. Buyer

confidence in certain pockets of Victoria is quietly evaporating, and the reasons have everything to do with policy, not economics.

Victoria has spent the better part of a decade treating property owners particularly landlords as a problem to be solved rather than a service to be supported. Stamp duty hikes, land tax changes,

the short-stay levy, new rental minimum standards, expanded renter rights, and the ever-present threat of further intervention have

stacked up into a formidable wall of disincentive. For anyone thinking about buying an investment property in this state, the calculus has shifted dramatically.

“If you treat the property market with contempt, it will do exactly the same back through rising rents and vanishing supply.”

A FEDERAL PILE-ON

—————–

Now add the federal government’s renewed appetite for taxing landlords more aggressively, and the picture darkens further. Talk of tightening negative gearing, revisiting capital gains tax concessions, and increasing compliance costs for investment property owners is sending a clear signal to the market: your capital is not welcome here. Not, at least, unless you’re prepared to absorb the cost.

And absorb it they will but not in the way governments seem to imagine. The costs don’t disappear. They migrate. They move from landlords’ balance sheets directly onto the rental market, in the

form of higher rents and fewer available properties. The people who suffer most are not the wealthy investors governments are targeting.

They are the renters the young, the low income, the newly arrived who find themselves competing for a shrinking pool of rental stock at prices they cannot sustain.

It is one of the great ironies of modern housing policy: punish the suppliers, and you punish the most vulnerable consumers. Every policy designed to hurt landlords ends up hurting renters more.

THE POLITICS OF ENVY, DRESSED AS POLICY

—————————————-

There is a pattern worth naming plainly. State and federal governments have embraced the idea that owning multiple properties is a moral failing. The language around housing policy in Australia

has shifted from economic management to something far more ideological: a conviction that landlords are extracting wealth from society rather than providing a service within it.

This framing is as politically convenient as it is economically illiterate. Rental housing does not materialise from goodwill and progressive sentiment. It comes from private investors many of them ordinary Australians with a single investment property, not shadowy property barons who are willing to tie up their capital in exchange for a reasonable return. Remove that return, or bury it under compliance costs and punitive taxes, and those investors leave. 

And when they leave, renters pay.

THE SHARE MARKET QUESTION NOBODY IS ASKING

——————————————-

Consider the double standard at the heart of all this. No government in Australia would dream of introducing a vacancy tax on share portfolios, or demanding that equity investors justify their holdings to a regulator, or imposing minimum standards on the quality of returns they provide to the economy. The idea would be laughed out of any serious policy forum.

Yet all of these interventions in various forms have been applied to the property market without significant public backlash. Why?

Because property ownership, unlike share ownership, has been successfully framed as an identity issue. The landlord is a stock villain in Australia’s current cultural moment. The share market

investor is not.

No government would introduce a vacancy tax on share portfolios. 

The idea would be laughed away yet its property equivalent sailed through without blinking.

This is identity politics applied to housing and it produces bad policy, consistently, because it starts from a moral conclusion and works backwards to find justifications for punishment.

THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM

————————-

There is one more thing worth saying, and it deserves to be said without apology. A substantial proportion of the politicians who have championed the most aggressive anti-landlord policies own investment properties themselves. This is a matter of public record, disclosed in parliamentary registers of interests across both state and federal levels.

The hypocrisy is breath taking, but it is also instructive. It tells you that the people designing these policies understand, at some level, that property investment is a legitimate and rational financial choice. They make that choice themselves. They simply prefer that the rhetoric remain pointed elsewhere at the faceless landlord class, rather than at the people writing the legislation.

WHAT COMES NEXT

—————

The 72% clearance rate will not collapse overnight. Markets are resilient, and even battered ones find ways to clear. But the structural damage being done to investor confidence in Victoria and increasingly across the country will take years to repair.

Supply pipelines are thinning. Rental vacancies are already at historic lows in many areas. Rents are climbing. None of this is a mystery.

The chickens, as they say, have come home to roost. Victoria built the coop, the federal government is adding extra perches, and somehow everyone seems surprised that there are more birds than

expected. Until policy is built around how markets actually work rather than how politicians wish they did renters will keep paying for the ideology of their landlords’ opponents.

LET"S TALK
Send us a message and we will get back to you promptly.
PHONE
0402 149 966